

China produces a blockbuster akin to RRR.
Hoping this one comes true. RRR was tight
China produces a blockbuster akin to RRR.
Hoping this one comes true. RRR was tight
I wont touch grass until a group of people knocks on my door and harass me into join them
Jehovah’s Witnessing intensifies
It’s their loss tbh
They’re just embarrassed Israel supporters and anti-Palestinian racists. As others have pointed out, the whole ‘it’s too complex’ thing is a convenient excuse to continue the status quo. What goes unspoken in their line of thought is that we’re already intervening but on the side of supporting the genocide. It’s not inaction that they want, but the maintenance of current actions
Ah okay, yeah, I misunderstood. Thanks for clarifying
Sex club membership/paying a sex worker is a way better (and less harmful) way to spend that money than like 60% of the things US taxes are likely to be spent on so got to support this tbh
Yeah, that’s fair, I don’t have much of a grasp of the specifics of the case beyond the article. And I agree that tipping is worse than non-tipped waged work under sectoral collective bargaining and that we should have the latter as our goal as long as we remain within a capitalist framework. Indeed, from my experience, in a lot of places where tipping isn’t customary and they do have sectoral bargaining waiters take it as something of an affront to be tipped. French waiters are often somewhat offended by attempts to tip them - precisely because it is perceived as an attack on their dignity as workers.
But I still think that we should be careful in uncritically supporting the abolition of tipping outside of circumstances in which a sector is sufficiently well-organised. We’ve seen so many examples in the last few decades in which often positive reforms, which were initially demanded by workers, have been co-opted by capital to undermine conditions and wages precisely because those reforms took place in a general context where workers haven’t been well-organised enough to defend themselves against the attacks of capital. The demand for flexible working practices/hours in the 1970s and 80s is a good example of this process, where what should have been positive reforms have had extremely mixed results in that they’ve played a large role in creating conditions of casualisation and mass under-employment. In many sectors, ‘flexible working’ has meant flexibility to work sporadic hours whenever your boss decides with the knowledge that if you’re not sufficiently flexible to their demands you’ll stop being given work.
I also do think that the ‘it divides the working class’ argument is the weakest one, because what it really ends up expressing is a consoomer mindset that as communists/anarchists we should challenge rather than accept. While I’m sure that our comrades on here are arguing in good faith and have decent reasons for wanting to abolish tipping, this isn’t representative of the debate overall. Most of the discourse I’ve encountered on the topic has been on reddit and is predictably treat-brained. The framing is almost always primarily ‘tipping is too expensive!’ with questions about the conditions/rights of workers relegated to a secondary position that often feels tacked on to cover that the primary demand is ‘I want things to be cheaper even if that means workers are paid less’. You can say this is unfair, but the last 40 years of economic reform have shown us that people who identify more strongly with being a consumer than a worker will buy the cheaper commodity made by workers labouring under worse conditions and less pay 99 times out of 100
Ayyy, no worries and I appreciate you acknowledging the mistake I don’t really know enough about the issue to have a very strong opinion on it, I was mainly just annoyed that so few people in the thread seemed to have read the thing they were responding to, but I’m also guilty of that quite often on here! Do you know of anything I can read to get better informed?
You’re all over this thread calling the workers scabs when the article says they were asking for a pooled-tip structure. At least read the thing before hurling insults at people
Countries that don’t have tipping tend to have sectoral collective bargaining, which (at least ideally) ensures a relatively good wage for all workers in a sector. If there are levels of unionisation/worker organisation that can make this a reality in the US, then go for it. However, in the absence of that Janny’s post makes a lot of useful points about the potential effects of a capital-led transition to tip-free work. It strikes me like almost no one in this thread has even read the article that we’re all notionally discussing. I admit I don’t know what the positions of the presumably numerous US restaurant workers’ unions are on these questions, but the article states that these workers were being advised by one and wanted to retain a pooled-tip structure
But the article literally talks about them asking for a pooled-tip structure and that they were being supported by the union. One of the workers says that the $30 an hour is a 40% pay cut
I get where you’re coming from, but if they make more with tips shouldn’t we support them keeping tips?
On the one hand, ‘autonomous’ vehicles suck. On the other hand, they tried to run over a finance worker…
This happening was inevitable when European liberals decided that criticism of Israel is anti-semitism
Yeah, that’s true, and Biden may well win. We’ll see one way or another. But I would say that promises of what you’d do in power are much more convincing when you’re not already in power and not doing whatever you’re promising
Not running a meaningful campaign was literally Biden’s successful strategy. Given that neither party can any longer offer the majority of Americans any improvement in their standard of living, I think we’ll increasingly see one term presidents as people just vote against the person they’ve seen the most of most recently and so dislike the most intensely, i.e. the incumbent
Ayyy, marone! As a 60th generation survivor of the sack of Rome, this is very disrespectful!
They gave me a hate name, and you’re laughing?!
Dads Rock