• @Zozano@aussie.zone
    link
    fedilink
    3
    edit-2
    1 year ago

    You seem to be assuming a lot about my position, and getting most of it wrong.

    My only stance thus far is one of definitions. Yes, I know the definition of “pride” has changed, which I’m trying to illustrate is an issue.

    Elon’s “white pride” rhetoric stems from nationalism, which stems from the conventional definition of “pride”, which is:

    a feeling of deep pleasure or satisfaction derived from one’s own achievements, the achievements of those with whom one is closely associated, or from qualities or possessions that are widely admired

    The pride displayed here is that of perceived inherent superiority, which leads to bigotry.

    Rationality and emotion aren’t mutually exclusive. Empathy has flaws, it causes people to become hijacked by emotion. Conversely, compassion is a choice, even psychopaths can be convinced behaving compassionately is in their own self interest.

    So, I don’t accept the assertion that feelings are an acceptable metric for evaluating the validity of a claim. I’m convinced it’s wrong to be proud of an identity.

      • @aesthelete@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        -2
        edit-2
        1 year ago

        I’ve always struggled to see the upside to celebrating any sort of heritage

        And I’ve always struggled to see the upside to celebrating the community team or whatever, but that doesn’t make my opinion more rational, valuable, or human than anyone else’s.

        folk can be happy about whatever, I guess, as long as they’re not denigrating others.

        “Whatever” “I guess”… These words aren’t in here by accident, but this overall sentiment is the one actually worth pursuing IMO without all of the passive aggression.

        You and the Aussie don’t seem to understand that you’re advancing Musk’s (and other racists’) “arguments” by equating overwhelmingly positive movements with reactionary, retrograde movements that use co-opted words and rhetorical tricks to pretend they’re the same thing.

          • @aesthelete@lemmy.world
            link
            fedilink
            -1
            edit-2
            1 year ago

            Can a gay person who has never experienced homophobia rightfully celebrate Pride Month?

            Can a black person who was adopted by white parents and has no black cultural influence be proud of being black?

            Edit: ya ever wonder why you’re talking about legitimate events for black people and gay people in a thread commenting about Elon Musk’s endorsement of “white pride”? It’s because you got "all lives matter"ed and lost the fucking plot.

              • @Zozano@aussie.zone
                link
                fedilink
                2
                edit-2
                1 year ago

                Those are my quotes.

                I stopped conversing with them after they misquoted me after replacing “rightfully” with “morally”.

                Don’t waste your time trying to change their mind, they’ve already decided you’re the one who’s wrong.

                The worst part is we’re evidently all on the same team, yet we’re made out to be Elon supporters.

    • @aesthelete@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      -11 year ago

      Elon’s “white pride” rhetoric stems from nationalism, which stems from the convention definition of “pride”

      You’re acting like Elon or a klansman (same picture.gif) sat down and read a dictionary definition and came up with this. He didn’t.

      Rationality and emotion aren’t mutually exclusive. Empathy has flaws, it causes people to become hijacked by emotion. Conversely, compassion is a choice, even psychopaths can be convinced behaving compassionately is in their own self interest.

      Of course they’re not mutually exclusive, you were pretending they were by saying someone’s “correct” feeling of pride can only be derived from their own achievements.

      Rationality is a man made concept. Humans are not purely or perhaps not even mostly rational.

      So, I don’t accept the assertion that feelings are an acceptable metric for evaluating the validity of a claim.

      What claim are you even talking about? You’re the one tossing out claims left and right, like it’s morally wrong to go to a pride parade unless you’ve personally experienced homophobia… Meanwhile you’re side stepping the very relevant and obvious thing: that someone acting positively due to unearned pride harms absolutely nobody.

      You’re getting confused by rhetoric because you’re overly concerned about the dictionary definition of co-opted words. Just because it’s called white pride and gay pride doesn’t mean that the intentions, the events, the attendants, or anything philosophically backing any of it are remotely the same. Straight pride is practically a homophobic hatred event, gay pride is largely a block party with fun and revelry.

      • @Zozano@aussie.zone
        link
        fedilink
        11 year ago

        It’s evident you’re arguing in bad faith. I never claimed its morally wrong to attend a pride parade unless one has experience homophobia. I’m out, peace

        • @aesthelete@lemmy.world
          link
          fedilink
          1
          edit-2
          1 year ago

          It’s exactly counter to your main position about how only certain people are allowed to feel pride based upon certain earned criteria. But you do you, bud.

          I wish you and people like you weren’t so simply fooled by tricks of rhetoric as you are. But not only is that unlikely to change, you’re likely to continue thinking you’re actually technically correct in some way because you have a dictionary definition of a term and think that’s an argument.

          White pride != black pride

          Straight pride != gay pride

          Black lives matter != all lives matter

          Edit: y’all are right, these things are exactly the same because they use similar language in their names… That’s definitely not what a retrograde shit movement would do to try to lend legitimacy to their bullshit… That’s definitely not similar to what North Korea does by calling itself the “People’s Democratic Republic of Korea” or anything. /s