• @OwenEverbinde@lemmy.myserv.one
    link
    fedilink
    English
    5
    edit-2
    1 year ago

    Depends on how you define capitalism.

    According to the modern (very intentionally altered) definition of capitalism,

    “a system allowing the exchange of goods and services for currency, where different skill sets can result in different compensation”

    … everything, including the USSR [1][2] has been capitalism. And even most Marxists are pro-capitalists.

    The definition above encompasses everything that ever was, and everything that ever will be. (And that’s only a slight exaggeration)

    Which – just fyi – makes the word one of the most useless words in the history of language.

    If, however – just hypothetically – you wanted to have a productive dialogue with a self-described anti-capitalist, you would need to carry out the entire conversation pretending the word “capitalism” referred to something a hell of a lot more specific. A single mechanism within market society. A single kind of contractual relationship between worker and company.

    Which is an exercise in imagination and in the algebraic concept of substitution that most people have a rather stubborn aversion to.

    • The barter system before currency was invented wouldn’t fit that definition, and strictly speaking Marx wanted Communism to do away with currency so if that ever happened anywhere, that would also be outside of that definition.

      That being said, yeah the modern definition of “capitalism” is over-broad and mostly useless as a concept.

      • @OwenEverbinde@lemmy.myserv.one
        link
        fedilink
        English
        5
        edit-2
        1 year ago

        Right. That is a good point. Although Marx didn’t see the elimination of currency as a realistic goal attainable within the first few decades (possibly even the first century) of communism, he did believe a post-scarcity humanity would eventually transcend the need for currency.

        However when it comes to barter, the thing is: even in societies dominated by barter, some commodity tends to become the standard against which the values of other commodities are measured. Cigarettes in POW camps, cacao beans in Mesoamerica.

        By an admittedly-loose definition of currency, a currency does always emerge and end up being directly exchanged for goods and services, even in barter systems.